I haven't got my reads quite figured out yet this early in the game, so at the moment I'm hesitant to provide a list.
forum
NewD3 -- NES [Town win] 521i69
posted
Total Posts
364
i read the deadline wrong and got put on the spot by samx. then i made an absolute trash post about how you are scum based on only one reason + vote you. then i realised the dealine changed.ShinRun wrote: 4p6j2
Cleve - Cleveland is also pushing really hard to vote me off and his excuse of not reading correctly seems really suspicious. The only reason he unvoted me is that others were gonna vote him off.
i said UnvoteDCT wrote: 4w3f2c
ShinRun: (1) ClevelandsMyBro
No shit I super aggressive when town is a vote a away from lynching a pr townie. You should be too. I have no idea why people doubt Shin can be town. I have no idea why Shin's claim is fake. It just doesn't make sense for it to be fake.manishmathur wrote: 49y5n
abraker on the other hand feel super aggressive and I think he is just trying to make us confuse to who to vote.
VOTE abraker
Since my last post my suspicion are still on Cleveland and igorsprite. They both removed their vote but it may be damage control after realizing that they couldn't get ShinRun voted out.
For now I'll park my vote on cleveland for now, that puts them at E-2
VOTE: ClevelandsMyBro
Outside of those two I don't suspect anyone else enough to vote them instead. On thing to point out is Julian_Kaiser and manishmathur are both voting for abraker right now. But it seems just like bad play to me, not necessarily scum play.
For now I'll park my vote on cleveland for now, that puts them at E-2
VOTE: ClevelandsMyBro
Outside of those two I don't suspect anyone else enough to vote them instead. On thing to point out is Julian_Kaiser and manishmathur are both voting for abraker right now. But it seems just like bad play to me, not necessarily scum play.
i was thinking that if we were in a setup that we didn't have PR we would be giving you both too much credit, but then i changed my mind and decided to wait day 2 to see what would happen.abraker wrote: 6cx2d
Now that we know Shin was town, I'd really like to know your thought process in why you were at odds against my efforts trying to convince everyone that Shin was indeed town.igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
idk why abraker insists that shin is town.
???? wut but... we were given the setupigorsprite wrote: 6x186x
i was thinking that if we were in a setup that we didn't have PR we would be giving you both too much credit, but then i changed my mind and decided to wait day 2 to see what would happen.abraker wrote: 6cx2d
Now that we know Shin was town, I'd really like to know your thought process in why you were at odds against my efforts trying to convince everyone that Shin was indeed town.igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
idk why abraker insists that shin is town.
DCT wrote: 4w3f2c
In detail, we've got 5 vanillas, 2 random power roles, and 2 scum (one of them can have special powers)igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
newd3 is a 2v7 setup and you just made the game 100% easier for the mafia by claiming your roleShinRun wrote: 4p6j2
I have been forgetting to check this game lol
Hmmmm so based on the role example, it seems like 6 are town while 3 are mafia
I think we should start by claiming roles soooo Im a town doctor
arent all the setup have atleast one PR anyways?igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
i was thinking that if we were in a setup that we didn't have PR we would be giving you both too much credit, but then i changed my mind and decided to wait day 2 to see what would happen.abraker wrote: 6cx2d
Now that we know Shin was town, I'd really like to know your thought process in why you were at odds against my efforts trying to convince everyone that Shin was indeed town.igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
idk why abraker insists that shin is town.
noClevelandsMyBro wrote: 58np
arent all the setup have atleast one PR anyways?
oh, i didn't see that xDabraker wrote: 6cx2d
???? wut but... we were given the setup
DCT wrote: 4w3f2c
In detail, we've got 5 vanillas, 2 random power roles, and 2 scum (one of them can have special powers)igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
newd3 is a 2v7 setup and you just made the game 100% easier for the mafia by claiming your roleShinRun wrote: 4p6j2
I have been forgetting to check this game lol
Hmmmm so based on the role example, it seems like 6 are town while 3 are mafia
I think we should start by claiming roles soooo Im a town doctor
hmm that seem weird for you to glance over someone's response of your quoteigorsprite wrote: 6x186x
oh, i didn't see that xDabraker wrote: 6cx2d
???? wut but... we were given the setup
DCT wrote: 4w3f2c
In detail, we've got 5 vanillas, 2 random power roles, and 2 scum (one of them can have special powers)igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
newd3 is a 2v7 setup and you just made the game 100% easier for the mafia by claiming your roleShinRun wrote: 4p6j2
I have been forgetting to check this game lol
Hmmmm so based on the role example, it seems like 6 are town while 3 are mafia
I think we should start by claiming roles soooo Im a town doctor
huuuuh??igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
noClevelandsMyBro wrote: 58np
arent all the setup have atleast one PR anyways?
Mafia is now certain what the role selection are, puts them at a high advantage while we are still uncertain, being at a disadvantage.
Although I still haven't made any deductions to say otherwise.
I feel like Manish is just saying this out of spite.The Indian Guy wrote: 2fy6t
I still think abraker is sus
Although I still haven't made any deductions to say otherwise.
Cleveland was the only member to vote Shin and unvote after his mistake, was his tactic to vote off a town member for the sole reason that he made an early roleclaim to attempt making him look scum?
Anyway, as I can't think of a better option rn..
Vote: ClevelandsMyBro
This is also what he could have tried, but that's just a possibility.abraker wrote: 6cx2d
Switching votes to pressure people is a valid scum hunting tactic.
Anyway, as I can't think of a better option rn..
Vote: ClevelandsMyBro
so now Cleveland is at E-2.
We should still wait until the last few days to discuss more.
I would be fine with voting for cleveland but I am much more certain about Igorsprite being scum. I don't believe in their explanation that they just didn't understand the setup.
We should still wait until the last few days to discuss more.
No, Igorsprite also did the same, that's why Igorsprite and Cleveland are the two biggest suspect right now.Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q
Cleveland was the only member to vote Shin and unvote after his mistake
I would be fine with voting for cleveland but I am much more certain about Igorsprite being scum. I don't believe in their explanation that they just didn't understand the setup.
This is a... Confusing move. While Manish definitely has made some Interesting choices throughout this game, I think it would be better worth our time to focus on the people making sketchy plays that actually know the game rather than the person who is confused at every turn.NotRaffi wrote: 171b11
Vote:Manishmanthur
my main reasoning was because of shin's skip voting.Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q
Cleveland was the only member to vote Shin and unvote after his mistake, was his tactic to vote off a town member for the sole reason that he made an early roleclaim to attempt making him look scum?
community/forums/topics/1480949?n=93
nope. my vote was legitimate.Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q
This is also what he could have tried, but that's just a possibility.abraker wrote: 6cx2d
Switching votes to pressure people is a valid scum hunting tactic.
do it. but if i turned out to be town then give igor a thorough look tomorrow. unlike shin, you're not gonna lose anything for voting me out.samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
I'd still prefer to vote off Igorsprite today but I can cast the hammer if you are okay with that.
If you tell me it's okay I am switching my vote to cleveland.
do it. but if i turned out to be town then give igor a thorough look tomorrow. unlike shin, you're not gonna lose anything for voting me out.[/quote]samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
I'd still prefer to vote off Igorsprite today but I can cast the hammer if you are okay with that.
If you tell me it's okay I am switching my vote to cleveland.
We still have two full days to discuss. We are about to vote you off but don't just give up. You seem to be on to Igor, tell us why you think they are more likely scum than you.
Knowing your vote was legitimate, I now have more suspicion towards you due to the fact you tried to vote off a possibleClevelandsMyBro wrote: 58np
my main reasoning was because of shin's skip voting.Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q
Cleveland was the only member to vote Shin and unvote after his mistake, was his tactic to vote off a town member for the sole reason that he made an early roleclaim to attempt making him look scum?
community/forums/topics/1480949?n=93
nope. my vote was legitimate.Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q
This is also what he could have tried, but that's just a possibility.abraker wrote: 6cx2d
Switching votes to pressure people is a valid scum hunting tactic.
Likely could be that you're mafia and you knew it was your opportunity to wipe off a town member with the probability of having a PR removed from town.
His silence is really sus. I think something like this happened in prev game and they flipped town. Cleve, you should defend yourself. You a risking in screwing up town otherwise.ghoulybits wrote: v2x52
Cleve, it's in your best interest if you're town to actually defend yourself rather than give up. Please tell us more about what you think.
Not much is said, but this makes me hesitant about Cleveland.ClevelandsMyBro wrote: 58np
do it. but if i turned out to be town then give igor a thorough look tomorrow. unlike shin, you're not gonna lose anything for voting me out.
My asumption was that they were scum buddy with Igor, but now they are flipping on Igor.
I am extremely sure that Igor is scum, so Cleveland being against them makes me reconsider my assumption. I think Cleveland might be town, or they are scum buddy and trying to hide their connection.
Btw, we still know that we have for sure either a town tracker or a town cop during the game, both of which can tell who is scum.
If we have a cop, they can obviously figure out a scum, and if we have a tracker, the only player who can make an action is scum, so they act basically the same as a cop (assuming there is only one mafia)
I think the best course of action is to eliminate Igor and then let our tracker or cop investigate Cleveland to determine if they are scum.
I guess the only way to find out a mafia member(if we still haven't kicked out one) is to sacrifice out town PR, which is risky in itself.
Instructing the town PR to reveal his role when he's found out scum member the next day, collectively vote off mafia and lose the only PR.
Or: Keep waiting till PR has received both the roles of mafia(if he manages to survive that far) and we'd win.
Instructing the town PR to reveal his role when he's found out scum member the next day, collectively vote off mafia and lose the only PR.
Or: Keep waiting till PR has received both the roles of mafia(if he manages to survive that far) and we'd win.
I agree with the plansamX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
Not much is said, but this makes me hesitant about Cleveland.ClevelandsMyBro wrote: 58np
do it. but if i turned out to be town then give igor a thorough look tomorrow. unlike shin, you're not gonna lose anything for voting me out.
My asumption was that they were scum buddy with Igor, but now they are flipping on Igor.
I am extremely sure that Igor is scum, so Cleveland being against them makes me reconsider my assumption. I think Cleveland might be town, or they are scum buddy and trying to hide their connection.
Btw, we still know that we have for sure either a town tracker or a town cop during the game, both of which can tell who is scum.
If we have a cop, they can obviously figure out a scum, and if we have a tracker, the only player who can make an action is scum, so they act basically the same as a cop (assuming there is only one mafia)
I think the best course of action is to eliminate Igor and then let our tracker or cop investigate Cleveland to determine if they are scum.
unvote: cleveland
why igor? he was way too cooperative day one. especially here. he casually agrees to my absolute trainwreck of a reasoning why i voted shin. it took 1 post from samx to completely change his mind but he completely ignored all the post defending shin before it. so my hypothesis here is igor tried to bandwagon my vote but turns arround as soon as someone saw something fishy.
another reason? two different reasoning why he voted shin.
honestly re reading all of this makes me think he's more of an incompetent. but knowing from previous games, he always seems to be really competitive so this is really uncanny behaviour.
another reason? two different reasoning why he voted shin.
igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
i didn't even notice that we only have 1 day left
i agree with clevelands, shin's roleclaim doesn't mean that he is town and him suggesting nolim contributes to my suspicions. idk why abraker insists that shin is town.
---igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
i was thinking that if we were in a setup that we didn't have PR we would be giving you both too much credit, but then i changed my mind and decided to wait day 2 to see what would happen.
honestly re reading all of this makes me think he's more of an incompetent. but knowing from previous games, he always seems to be really competitive so this is really uncanny behaviour.
my interest for this game is kinda low. thats it really. :shrug:abraker wrote: 6cx2d
His silence is really sus.