Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

Shinrun's roleclaim makes no sense to me. I am wondering if they are scum trying to push town to mass roleclaim by fake claiming a role.

Though I am not sure it's worth investigating since we'll have the answer by whether or not Shinrun dies this night. If they don't die tonight then they are probably a scum.

I don't see how him not dying tonight makes him a scum?

it's simple, why the mafia would not kill the doctor?

igorsprite wrote: 6x186x

Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

Shinrun's roleclaim makes no sense to me. I am wondering if they are scum trying to push town to mass roleclaim by fake claiming a role.

Though I am not sure it's worth investigating since we'll have the answer by whether or not Shinrun dies this night. If they don't die tonight then they are probably a scum.

I don't see how him not dying tonight makes him a scum?

it's simple, why the mafia would not kill the doctor?

It may sound simple as that, but at the same time doesn't guarantee his suspicion.
Why would they not kill?
-That happens when they found someone more suitable to kill.

Unless if that's not the case, then that raises the chance of him being scum.

igorsprite wrote: 6x186x

Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

Shinrun's roleclaim makes no sense to me. I am wondering if they are scum trying to push town to mass roleclaim by fake claiming a role.

Though I am not sure it's worth investigating since we'll have the answer by whether or not Shinrun dies this night. If they don't die tonight then they are probably a scum.

I don't see how him not dying tonight makes him a scum?

it's simple, why the mafia would not kill the doctor?

While I think it's more likely that Shin ends up dead than doesn't, it is possible that mafia could choose a more psychological route and purposefully not kill ShinRun because he revealed as doctor in order to put more suspicion on him if he doesn't die.

Shin honestly sounds so disingenuous. but its shin, so it may also be some stupid fuckery on his part. tho im leaning towards the former.

So I’m pretty much fucked this game either by being voted out or being killed so I’ll just explained tf happened in my head last night.

So before the game started, I didn’t even check what this game mode was so I had no idea what the comp was.

I was obviously given the doctor role and since there were 9 example roles and 9 players, I thought this would be a normal game of mafia where you could role claim. I was almost gonna leave my role out of the post but I kept it in for credibility.

This honestly gotta be the dumbest play I have done since I started play mafia

However if you guys decide to not vote me, three things could happen.

1. Mafia kill me tonight

2. Mafia target someone else and kill them, most likely resulting in me being voted out unless someone have a tracker role or smth

3. Mafia target someone and I protect the same person. This would prove that I’m innocent.

(C) 1985 Nintendo

Current votes 5o3y70

No elimination: (0)

Not voting: (9 players)

To vote, post VOTE: <someone> in bold font.
Deadline for day is 2021-12-21 04:00:00 UTC.

If mafia are veterans in this game they know how to play this out: Divide and conquer.

vote: SamX500

Ooh, getting feisty. I understand the reasoning, but I'm not quite ready to vote with minimal evidence.

abraker wrote: 6cx2d

If mafia are veterans in this game they know how to play this out: Divide and conquer.

vote: SamX500

It wasn't my intent to divide people by throwing suspicion on ShinRun. I was just pointing out that I didn't understand Shinrun's reasoning for role claiming (especially with such a valuable role) and that this is what I came up with tryibng to make sense of their action. I also wanted to warn the two town with role to not roleclaim in case ShinRun really is a scum.

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

abraker wrote: 6cx2d

If mafia are veterans in this game they know how to play this out: Divide and conquer.

vote: SamX500

It wasn't my intent to divide people by throwing suspicion on ShinRun. I was just pointing out that I didn't understand Shinrun's reasoning for role claiming (especially with such a valuable role) and that this is what I came up with tryibng to make sense of their action. I also wanted to warn the two town with role to not roleclaim in case ShinRun really is a scum.

why do you think that we have 2 town PR?

igorsprite wrote: 6x186x

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

abraker wrote: 6cx2d

If mafia are veterans in this game they know how to play this out: Divide and conquer.

vote: SamX500

It wasn't my intent to divide people by throwing suspicion on ShinRun. I was just pointing out that I didn't understand Shinrun's reasoning for role claiming (especially with such a valuable role) and that this is what I came up with tryibng to make sense of their action. I also wanted to warn the two town with role to not roleclaim in case ShinRun really is a scum.

why do you think that we have 2 town PR?

The setup is NewD3, so there are 2 town PR

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

igorsprite wrote: 6x186x

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

abraker wrote: 6cx2d

If mafia are veterans in this game they know how to play this out: Divide and conquer.

vote: SamX500

It wasn't my intent to divide people by throwing suspicion on ShinRun. I was just pointing out that I didn't understand Shinrun's reasoning for role claiming (especially with such a valuable role) and that this is what I came up with tryibng to make sense of their action. I also wanted to warn the two town with role to not roleclaim in case ShinRun really is a scum.

why do you think that we have 2 town PR?

The setup is NewD3, so there are 2 town PR

C1 and C2 sounds too unfair.
I hope this game didn't follow that setup

I think we should probably assume for the time being that we have two town PR unless given proof otherwise, since it's the most likely scenario. In addition, assuming ShinRun was being a total idiot and actually said his role, the only options for the set up would have to involve two town PR.

yea if shin is telling the truth and the game does contain 1 PR then i would legit think this game is dunzos.

@NotRaffi say something

He hasn't made a single post, why isn't he prodded?

bro when the fuck did I participated and i dont even know wtf is newd3

Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q

He hasn't made a single post, why isn't he prodded?

Already prodded once, and put his slot up for replacement after confirming that a moderation error happened.

manishmathur wrote: 49y5n

bro when the fuck did I participated and i dont even know wtf is newd3

(Repeat) Replacing manishmathur. Sorry for g you up by mistake.

(C) 1985 Nintendo

Current votes 5o3y70

samX500: (1) abraker
No elimination: (0)

Not voting: (8 players)

manishmathur is being replaced.
Deadline for day is extended to 2021-12-24 04:00:00 UTC.

sorry for not being active my dudes, was out for a while and need to preserve data, I'm just gonna read things

DCT wrote: 4w3f2c

Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q

He hasn't made a single post, why isn't he prodded?

Already prodded once, and put his slot up for replacement after confirming that a moderation error happened.

I was referring to NotRaffi

[quote="NotRaffi"]sorry for not being active my dudes, was out for a while and need to preserve data, I'm just gonna read things

Understandable. I hope this game doesn't die out.

Is editing my post allowed?

nah

There's no rule about it though

I rerewd the rules, i it my mistake

Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q

Is editing my post allowed?

No.

if whatever the game is and not required a thing that i dont have then i can replace to manishmathur

So what are our plan

I suggest not voting anyone off

ShinRun wrote: 4p6j2

I suggest not voting anyone off

why?

DCT wrote: 4w3f2c

Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q

He hasn't made a single post, why isn't he prodded?

Already prodded once, and put his slot up for replacement after confirming that a moderation error happened.

manishmathur wrote: 49y5n

bro when the fuck did I participated and i dont even know wtf is newd3

(Repeat) Replacing manishmathur. Sorry for g you up by mistake.

Should no one replace manishmathur in the next 36 hours, he get to keep his slot.

I think for now that no votes is probably a solid option. At the very least, even if he's suspicious, I don't think ShinRun should be voted. If he is telling the truth, that would be a major loss for town. If he's lying, then we'll probably figure that out by the next day.

Yeah i think that's good

igorsprite wrote: 6x186x

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

igorsprite wrote: 6x186x

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

abraker wrote: 6cx2d

If mafia are veterans in this game they know how to play this out: Divide and conquer.

vote: SamX500

It wasn't my intent to divide people by throwing suspicion on ShinRun. I was just pointing out that I didn't understand Shinrun's reasoning for role claiming (especially with such a valuable role) and that this is what I came up with tryibng to make sense of their action. I also wanted to warn the two town with role to not roleclaim in case ShinRun really is a scum.

why do you think that we have 2 town PR?

The setup is NewD3, so there are 2 town PR

What are trying to say with this? This game literally cannot be C1 or C2. I am going under the assumption you circled options that we can rule out.

Honestly it's either A1 or B3, and I am under certain belief Shin did not fake role claim.

ClevelandsMyBro wrote: 58np

yea if shin is telling the truth and the game does contain 1 PR then i would legit think this game is dunzos.

It contains 2 PRs.

ShinRun wrote: 4p6j2

So what are our plan

I suggest not voting anyone off

scum suggestion, try again

ghoulybits wrote: v2x52

I think for now that no votes is probably a solid option. At the very least, even if he's suspicious, I don't think ShinRun should be voted. If he is telling the truth, that would be a major loss for town. If he's lying, then we'll probably figure that out by the next day.

Not voting now is gonna suck later cause you have more chance voting out a PR if mafia has not done so by then.

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

abraker wrote: 6cx2d

If mafia are veterans in this game they know how to play this out: Divide and conquer.

vote: SamX500

It wasn't my intent to divide people by throwing suspicion on ShinRun. I was just pointing out that I didn't understand Shinrun's reasoning for role claiming (especially with such a valuable role) and that this is what I came up with tryibng to make sense of their action. I also wanted to warn the two town with role to not roleclaim in case ShinRun really is a scum.

It doesn't make sense for shin to role claim because he did not use any braincells when doing so. If I learned anything about how entirety of town thinks in the past whatever games it is that it always seems to have an ass for brain. The fact that there are people here hoping that there this game is not 1 PR proves this fact. It's already confirmed there are 2 PRs wtf guys.

Why is "not voting anyone off" always a "scum suggestion" ? What if shin is actually not capping

NotRaffi wrote: 171b11

Why is "not voting anyone off" always a "scum suggestion" ?

because not voting anyone off helps scum in the long run

NotRaffi wrote: 171b11

What if shin is actually not capping

Then vote me off before I get a stroke. Scum cant risk with role claim like this because
1) Town should not role claim this early
2) There be people like you who would want to then vote them out thinking it some scummy fake claim

DCT wrote: 4w3f2c

DCT wrote: 4w3f2c

Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q

He hasn't made a single post, why isn't he prodded?

Already prodded once, and put his slot up for replacement after confirming that a moderation error happened.

manishmathur wrote: 49y5n

bro when the fuck did I participated and i dont even know wtf is newd3

(Repeat) Replacing manishmathur. Sorry for g you up by mistake.

Should no one replace manishmathur in the next 36 hours, he get to keep his slot.

So in mean time can you tell me how this game work

Setup A1 and B3 both include a doctor so I think it’s either one of these.

The other PR should be a cop or tracker, the person with the ability could literally use the ability on me to see if I’m lying or not. A cop should be able to see my alignment and tracker can see if I protected someone with my ability. Worst case scenario, mafia kill me.

This is why I say we don’t vote off anyone.

Unless DCT is using two random PR

manishmathur wrote: 49y5n

DCT wrote: 4w3f2c

DCT wrote: 4w3f2c

Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q

He hasn't made a single post, why isn't he prodded?

Already prodded once, and put his slot up for replacement after confirming that a moderation error happened.

manishmathur wrote: 49y5n

bro when the fuck did I participated and i dont even know wtf is newd3

(Repeat) Replacing manishmathur. Sorry for g you up by mistake.

Should no one replace manishmathur in the next 36 hours, he get to keep his slot.

So in mean time can you tell me how this game work

community/forums/posts/1062604

abraker wrote: 6cx2d

manishmathur wrote: 49y5n

DCT wrote: 4w3f2c

DCT wrote: 4w3f2c

Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q

He hasn't made a single post, why isn't he prodded?

Already prodded once, and put his slot up for replacement after confirming that a moderation error happened.

manishmathur wrote: 49y5n

bro when the fuck did I participated and i dont even know wtf is newd3

(Repeat) Replacing manishmathur. Sorry for g you up by mistake.

Should no one replace manishmathur in the next 36 hours, he get to keep his slot.

So in mean time can you tell me how this game work

community/forums/posts/1062604

I understand fully nope

ShinRun wrote: 4p6j2

Unless DCT is using two random PR

This is not the case.

ShinRun wrote: 4p6j2

The other PR should be a cop or tracker, the person with the ability could literally use the ability on me to see if I’m lying or not. A cop should be able to see my alignment and tracker can see if I protected someone with my ability. Worst case scenario, mafia kill me.

sounds like youre begging for the other PR at night to prove your innocence.

if you are telling truth then the "worst case scenario" is at an all time high dude. there is no way mafia is gonna leave you alive tomorrow. its a clear line for them. all this no voting m'jick is way to risky for you and for townies sake.

ShinRun wrote: 4p6j2

The other PR should be a cop or tracker, the person with the ability could literally use the ability on me to see if I’m lying or not. A cop should be able to see my alignment and tracker can see if I protected someone with my ability. Worst case scenario, mafia kill me.

bad idea, you are basically saying to other PR to roleclaim day 2

What if you guys voted out the other PR in today

igorsprite wrote: 6x186x

ShinRun wrote: 4p6j2

The other PR should be a cop or tracker, the person with the ability could literally use the ability on me to see if I’m lying or not. A cop should be able to see my alignment and tracker can see if I protected someone with my ability. Worst case scenario, mafia kill me.

bad idea, you are basically saying to other PR to roleclaim day 2

If we vote out a town today and mafia kill tonight, it would be 5-2

If we vote out an town again day 2 and mafia kills, it would be 3-2

On day 3, game would end if we vote out another town

Role claim day 2 doesn’t sound that bad to me

In case you are a town doc:

Day 1: Mafia kills you everyone vote town. 5v2

Day 2: Everyone obediently roleclaims and votes out town again and Mafia kills the other PR.
3v2

Day 3: everyone votes out town, or mafia and Mafia wins flawlessly. As nothing can keep them from winning during the night.

The game ending would already be decided by day 2 if mafia's plans goes accordingly.

Almost the same scenario you predicted above even if roleclaim day 2 was mandated.

so yeah, "Role claim day 2 doesn't sound that bad..."

Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q

Day 2: Everyone obediently roleclaims and votes out town again and Mafia kills the other PR.
3v2

By this, I meant Mafia can easily disguise as town.

You do realize that role claim only applies if I’m still alive day 2 so I can be proven as town or else I’m voted out. If I die tonight then there is no point in the other PR coming out

I can't believe we are arguing over when to roleclaim




How about we do scum hunting. Or have ya'll braincell counts hit below 0 somehow?

Ight sure

VOTE : Ghouly

You're making me regret advocating for you.

I feel like voting someone off carries a lot more risk than it does reward right now, and it's unlikely any wagon will actually get enough votes to eliminate before someone says "wait this is stupid" and everyone unvotes.

That being said, if we are going to vote, I'd specifically like to hear from the people who've been quiet for the majority of this game. Put yourself out there.

@ghoulybits

You say "I feel like voting someone off carries a lot more risk than it does reward right now". Is that just a guts feeling or is there any actual reasoning behind it?

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

@ghoulybits

You say "I feel like voting someone off carries a lot more risk than it does reward right now". Is that just a guts feeling or is there any actual reasoning behind it?

I think my main reasoning is that a lot of people in this game have either been extremely inactive or have otherwise given very little input other than posting. Those people are more likely to go under the radar when it comes time to choose someone to vote out (and choosing someone to vote out d1 is often just a random selection). If one or both scum are inactive during this period, they likely won't be considered as someone "worthy" of voting out. For example (and this is not a serious accusation, so please do not take it as one), what if Manish or whoever ends up in Manish's slot is scum? We would have literally no way of telling at this point, considering he knows absolutely zilch about how to play mafia and would likely show no suspicious activity. When it comes time for people to make a random vote or a vote solely based off of suspicion, they would likely leave him out of their considerations, considering he has said almost nothing besides that he doesn't know the game at all. Because of that, I think it's risky to vote anyone before we get everyone actively participating and showing their logic.

In addition, when it comes to voting out someone who's been more active in this game, I specifically have qualms with attempting to vote ShinRun, as I think that he's 1. an idiot who would actually roleclaim d1 and 2. most likely the town doctor. Therefore, that combined with the lack of any evidence to draw upon means that I would rather not vote someone out without an extremely compelling reason.

This is probably just word soup, so let me know if I need to clarify anything.

Ghouly I didn’t vote for you with the intention of voting you off day 1

It was to see your reaction

So i think we're gonna vote today?

ghoulybits wrote: v2x52

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

@ghoulybits

You say "I feel like voting someone off carries a lot more risk than it does reward right now". Is that just a guts feeling or is there any actual reasoning behind it?

I think my main reasoning is that a lot of people in this game have either been extremely inactive or have otherwise given very little input other than posting. Those people are more likely to go under the radar when it comes time to choose someone to vote out (and choosing someone to vote out d1 is often just a random selection). If one or both scum are inactive during this period, they likely won't be considered as someone "worthy" of voting out. For example (and this is not a serious accusation, so please do not take it as one), what if Manish or whoever ends up in Manish's slot is scum? We would have literally no way of telling at this point, considering he knows absolutely zilch about how to play mafia and would likely show no suspicious activity. When it comes time for people to make a random vote or a vote solely based off of suspicion, they would likely leave him out of their considerations, considering he has said almost nothing besides that he doesn't know the game at all. Because of that, I think it's risky to vote anyone before we get everyone actively participating and showing their logic.

In addition, when it comes to voting out someone who's been more active in this game, I specifically have qualms with attempting to vote ShinRun, as I think that he's 1. an idiot who would actually roleclaim d1 and 2. most likely the town doctor. Therefore, that combined with the lack of any evidence to draw upon means that I would rather not vote someone out without an extremely compelling reason.

This is probably just word soup, so let me know if I need to clarify anything.

so we should vote for who is less active

I'm a good choice but I'm ton

Dave or Atox, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Cover art (C) 1987 Nintendo

Current votes 5o3y70

samX500: (1) abraker
ghoulybits: (1) ShinRun
No elimination: (0)

Not voting: (7 players)

manishmathur is being replaced.
Deadline for day is 2021-12-24 04:00:00 UTC.

igorsprite wrote: 6x186x

so we should vote for who is less active

Abraker will probably call this a terrible idea

abraker wrote: 6cx2d

I can't believe we are arguing over when to roleclaim

How about we do scum hunting?

The thought of you dropping roleclaim idea sounds pretty scum.
Vote: abraker

While scum hunting has always been the route, it is also viable to decide when to roleclaim before things become more disastrous.
For now, we'll take decisions together on whom the town PR should Target without telling him/her to reveal his/her role.

Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q

abraker wrote: 6cx2d

I can't believe we are arguing over when to roleclaim

How about we do scum hunting?

The thought of you dropping roleclaim idea sounds pretty scum.
Vote: abraker

Because it's too early to even consider that. It takes away focus from what we should be doing: SCUM HUNTING

Roleclaiming right now is probably not a good idea. While it could help to either legitimize or delegitimize ShinRun's claims, it's also essentially putting a target on someone's back when it isn't necessary this early into the game.

@NotRaffi
@ClevelandsMyBro

Who would you vote today?

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

@NotRaffi
@ClevelandsMyBro

Who would you vote today?

gonna stick to my guts and vote the most obvious man since the begining. shin's "not voting" plan killed all my thought of him being town.

Vote: Shinrun

we dont have much time left. you lot need to make up your minds.

Cleveland is the second scum btw.

ha. vote me out then.

Cleveland

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

@NotRaffi
@ClevelandsMyBro

Who would you vote today?

I think I'm just gonna drop the last vote

The Legend of Zelda is originally released in Japan on disk.
Poirier273 at English Wikipedia, CC BY 2.5, via Wikimedia Commons

Current votes 5o3y70

samX500: (1) abraker
ghoulybits: (1) ShinRun
abraker: (1) Julian_Kaiser
ShinRun: (1) ClevelandsMyBro
No elimination: (0)

Not voting: (7 players)

manishmathur is being replaced.
To vote, type VOTE: John Smith in bold font.
Deadline for day is 2021-12-24 04:00:00 UTC.

i didn't even notice that we only have 1 day left

i agree with clevelands, shin's roleclaim doesn't mean that he is town and him suggesting nolim contributes to my suspicions. idk why abraker insists that shin is town.

Vote: Shinrun

so now Shinrun is E-1. So imma give my thought.

I am most suspicious of igorsprite right now because they are acting very cooperative, which from previous game I have learned that they are mostly cooperative when being scum.

I also think voting ShinRun is the worst possible idea. If they are scum, we will know by next night. If they are town, we are saving scum the hassle of killing one of our PR.

i'd also be down with voting cleveland and possible ghouly, since both of them also voted ShinRun. Though Ghouly has contributed a lot more so i'd go with cleveland first.

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

I am most suspicious of igorsprite right now because they are acting very cooperative, which from previous game I have learned that they are mostly cooperative when being scum.

hey, i'm reformed now

igorsprite wrote: 6x186x

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

I am most suspicious of igorsprite right now because they are acting very cooperative, which from previous game I have learned that they are mostly cooperative when being scum.

hey, i'm reformed now

Then please explain why you are voting ShinRun so early. If they are truly town doctor, then us eliminating them means scum won't have to kill them and will be able to try and kill the second PR.

And if they are scum, they will be mostly revealed tommorow by them being still alive. With the off-chance that scum plays with fire and leaves them alive.

To me it seems like you are trying to get a free kill on a town PR.

? I didn't vote ShinRun. In fact, I have specifically been arguing the same points as you have to NOT vote him.

ghoulybits wrote: v2x52

? I didn't vote ShinRun. In fact, I have specifically been arguing the same points as you have to NOT vote him.

oh sorry, I am drunk. I thought that you had voted ShinRun earlier on when they voted you.

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

igorsprite wrote: 6x186x

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

I am most suspicious of igorsprite right now because they are acting very cooperative, which from previous game I have learned that they are mostly cooperative when being scum.

hey, i'm reformed now

Then please explain why you are voting ShinRun so early. If they are truly town doctor, then us eliminating them means scum won't have to kill them and will be able to try and kill the second PR.

And if they are scum, they will be mostly revealed tommorow by them being still alive. With the off-chance that scum plays with fire and leaves them alive.

To me it seems like you are trying to get a free kill on a town PR.

oke, i will wait and see what happens.

i was thinking that only the cop could confirm if shin is town or scum, but just by having 2 PR is enough. so i think that shin being alive day 2 will not be a problem

Unvote

igorsprite wrote: 6x186x

i didn't even notice that we only have 1 day left

i agree with clevelands, shin's roleclaim doesn't mean that he is town and him suggesting nolim contributes to my suspicions. idk why abraker insists that shin is town.

Vote: Shinrun

Please refer to the latest vote count post for deadline.

How to read a vote count entry:

Candidate: (number of voters) A list of players voting the candidate
ACertainScum: (1) TownMayor

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

I also think voting ShinRun is the worst possible idea. If they are scum, we will know by next night. If they are town, we are saving scum the hassle of killing one of our PR.

Basically this

It's in mafia's best interest to have ShinRun voted out during the day because they cannot guarantee they can kill him during the night. It's literally a shot in the dark as to whether ShinRun will protect himself or not, so leaving it up to a night time elimination chance is not ideal for them. In order to have ShinRun voted out during the data mafia must do everything they can to convince town that ShinRun is likely scum. This includes enforcing ideas that ShinRun fake claimed.

igorsprite wrote: 6x186x

idk why abraker insists that shin is town.

Did you not read any of my post here: community/forums/posts/8435874

It is disadvantageous for BOTH town and scum to roleclaim this early. It's bad for town because exactly this happens - they are accused and risk being lynched. It's bad for scum, ESPECIALLY when claiming a power role, because they can be called out on it later on and because like town they risk of being accused and lynched. For scum to roleclaim doctor you gotta feel like you might win the lottery. You must be out of you goddamn mind if you think Shin is scum, that or you are scum.

It's going to be 10x more disasterous for town if ShinRun turns up PR town than if he does as scum. It's best to wait when dealing with possible PR roles. Suppress your lizard brains for once and don't lynch when someone does an oops.


I'm more comfortable lynching Cleveland right now.

Vote: ClevelandsMyBro

igorsprite wrote: 6x186x

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

I am most suspicious of igorsprite right now because they are acting very cooperative, which from previous game I have learned that they are mostly cooperative when being scum.

hey, i'm reformed now

When has your calmer "reformed" demeanor ever hint that you are a townie?

igorsprite wrote: 6x186x

i didn't even notice that we only have 1 day left

We got more than 1 day left. A few actually...

ClevelandsMyBro wrote: 58np

igorsprite wrote: 6x186x

so we should vote for who is less active

ShinRun wrote: 4p6j2

Abraker will probably call this a terrible idea

But seriously, out of all times I thought that an inactive person might be scum, they never were. So I don't think it's a good idea based on past experience.

That's said, keep your eyes pealed on who suddenly becomes inactive 👀

I don't agree with the idea of lynching Shin as it could affect this game deeply.
While his role is not confirmed, it would lead to a great disadvantage for town if he does in fact turn out to be what he claims.

NotRaffi wrote: 171b11

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

@NotRaffi
@ClevelandsMyBro

Who would you vote today?

I think I'm just gonna drop the last vote

Whom do you think is innocent/would you not vote against?
Is there any one whom you believe is a townie, or has lesser chance of being mafia?

Also Manish, try answering the question above.

Here are the possible outcomes regarding ShinRun:

If ShinRun is scum and doesn't get voted out: we have two scum to hunt for instead of one (assuming that we don't somehow get the other scum in voting)
If ShinRun is scum and gets voted out: we have only one scum to fine, but town will still continue to die regardless
If ShinRun is telling the truth and doesn't get voted out: we have a doctor who can heal himself / any town member that puts themselves at risk during the day
If ShinRun is telling the truth and gets voted out: we lose the ability to heal as well as a member of town

(and of course there's also the possibility that ShinRun is a vanilla townie/other PR that's lying about being a doctor, but that would be... literally idiotic. ShinRun, I swear to god, if this is what you did I will never forgive you)

In my opinion, the potential downsides of voting ShinRun outweigh the potential upsides. At best town gets a small lead that could still be fucked up, at worst town is majorly crippled for the rest of the game. Anyone who continues to advocate for ShinRun's death is gambling far too much this early in the game.

Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q

Also Manish, try answering the question above.

I don't think he'll respond.

Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q

I don't agree with the idea of lynching Shin as it could affect this game deeply.
While his role is not confirmed, it would lead to a great disadvantage for town if he does in fact turn out to be what he claims.

NotRaffi wrote: 171b11

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

@NotRaffi
@ClevelandsMyBro

Who would you vote today?

I think I'm just gonna drop the last vote

Whom do you think is innocent/would you not vote against?
Is there any one whom you believe is a townie, or has lesser chance of being mafia?

Also Manish, try answering the question above.

You sus

How the heck i suppose to know who is innocent. I don't even know my role
Dont vote me

manishmathur wrote: 49y5n

Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q

I don't agree with the idea of lynching Shin as it could affect this game deeply.
While his role is not confirmed, it would lead to a great disadvantage for town if he does in fact turn out to be what he claims.

NotRaffi wrote: 171b11

samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d

@NotRaffi
@ClevelandsMyBro

Who would you vote today?

I think I'm just gonna drop the last vote

Whom do you think is innocent/would you not vote against?
Is there any one whom you believe is a townie, or has lesser chance of being mafia?

Also Manish, try answering the question above.

You sus

How the heck i suppose to know who is innocent. I don't even know the roles
Dont vote me

It is 2 scum, 5 vanilla town and 2 random town roles. There is a more detailed explanation of this setup.

ghoulybits wrote: v2x52

If ShinRun is telling the truth and doesn't get voted out: we have a doctor who can heal himself / any town member that puts themselves at risk during the day

A doctor can't heal themself.

Ok so i found my role

I thought that was some fucking bot promoting Nintendo xd

I will go with the majority

DCT wrote: 4w3f2c

ghoulybits wrote: v2x52

If ShinRun is telling the truth and doesn't get voted out: we have a doctor who can heal himself / any town member that puts themselves at risk during the day

A doctor can't heal themself.

Whoops, my bad. Some games I've played before have that as a mechanic, so I got confused. Thanks for the correction.

So lets vote shitruin

Evan-Amos, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Current votes 5o3y70

ghoulybits: (1) ShinRun
abraker: (1) Julian_Kaiser
ShinRun: (1) ClevelandsMyBro
ClevelandsMyBro: (1) abraker
No elimination: (0)

Not voting: (5 players)

manishmathur is being replaced.
Deadline for day is 2021-12-24 04:00:00 UTC.

To vote, type VOTE: John Smith in bold font:

[b]VOTE: John Smith[/b]

for god sakes mod. i thohught the deadline was today since the game start post says so.

since its not im gonna retract my vote from shin. honestly got way too ahead of myself when voting shin anyways yesterday due to my inability to read.

Unvote: Shinrun

abraker wrote: 6cx2d

I'm more comfortable lynching Cleveland right now.

Vote: ClevelandsMyBro

i understand abraker's vote. my lack of activity, contribution, and knowledge of the game makes me a prime victim of lynching (at least today). i dont have an excuse other than i suck really. and i also dont wanna bring up external reasons.

abraker wrote: 6cx2d

igorsprite wrote: 6x186x

i didn't even notice that we only have 1 day left

We got more than 1 day left. A few actually...

the yyyy/mm/dd confused me @.@

manishmathur wrote: 49y5n

So lets vote shitruin

here is a good tip;

dont be like me and read through all the 120 posts ot know what is happening. from there you can make a solid reasoning and argument who to vote.