eae
newd3 is a 2v7 setup and you just made the game 100% easier for the mafia by claiming your roleShinRun wrote: 4p6j2
I have been forgetting to check this game lol
Hmmmm so based on the role example, it seems like 6 are town while 3 are mafia
I think we should start by claiming roles soooo Im a town doctor
Wait whatigorsprite wrote: 6x186x
newd3 is a 2v7 setup and you just made the game 100% easier for the mafia by claiming your roleShinRun wrote: 4p6j2
I have been forgetting to check this game lol
Hmmmm so based on the role example, it seems like 6 are town while 3 are mafia
I think we should start by claiming roles soooo Im a town doctor
In detail, we've got 5 vanillas, 2 random power roles, and 2 scum (one of them can have special powers)igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
newd3 is a 2v7 setup and you just made the game 100% easier for the mafia by claiming your roleShinRun wrote: 4p6j2
I have been forgetting to check this game lol
Hmmmm so based on the role example, it seems like 6 are town while 3 are mafia
I think we should start by claiming roles soooo Im a town doctor
I don't see how him not dying tonight makes him a scum?samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
Shinrun's roleclaim makes no sense to me. I am wondering if they are scum trying to push town to mass roleclaim by fake claiming a role.
Though I am not sure it's worth investigating since we'll have the answer by whether or not Shinrun dies this night. If they don't die tonight then they are probably a scum.
it's simple, why the mafia would not kill the doctor?Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q
I don't see how him not dying tonight makes him a scum?samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
Shinrun's roleclaim makes no sense to me. I am wondering if they are scum trying to push town to mass roleclaim by fake claiming a role.
Though I am not sure it's worth investigating since we'll have the answer by whether or not Shinrun dies this night. If they don't die tonight then they are probably a scum.
It may sound simple as that, but at the same time doesn't guarantee his suspicion.igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
it's simple, why the mafia would not kill the doctor?Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q
I don't see how him not dying tonight makes him a scum?samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
Shinrun's roleclaim makes no sense to me. I am wondering if they are scum trying to push town to mass roleclaim by fake claiming a role.
Though I am not sure it's worth investigating since we'll have the answer by whether or not Shinrun dies this night. If they don't die tonight then they are probably a scum.
While I think it's more likely that Shin ends up dead than doesn't, it is possible that mafia could choose a more psychological route and purposefully not kill ShinRun because he revealed as doctor in order to put more suspicion on him if he doesn't die.igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
it's simple, why the mafia would not kill the doctor?Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q
I don't see how him not dying tonight makes him a scum?samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
Shinrun's roleclaim makes no sense to me. I am wondering if they are scum trying to push town to mass roleclaim by fake claiming a role.
Though I am not sure it's worth investigating since we'll have the answer by whether or not Shinrun dies this night. If they don't die tonight then they are probably a scum.
It wasn't my intent to divide people by throwing suspicion on ShinRun. I was just pointing out that I didn't understand Shinrun's reasoning for role claiming (especially with such a valuable role) and that this is what I came up with tryibng to make sense of their action. I also wanted to warn the two town with role to not roleclaim in case ShinRun really is a scum.abraker wrote: 6cx2d
If mafia are veterans in this game they know how to play this out: Divide and conquer.
vote: SamX500
why do you think that we have 2 town PR?samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
It wasn't my intent to divide people by throwing suspicion on ShinRun. I was just pointing out that I didn't understand Shinrun's reasoning for role claiming (especially with such a valuable role) and that this is what I came up with tryibng to make sense of their action. I also wanted to warn the two town with role to not roleclaim in case ShinRun really is a scum.abraker wrote: 6cx2d
If mafia are veterans in this game they know how to play this out: Divide and conquer.
vote: SamX500
The setup is NewD3, so there are 2 town PRigorsprite wrote: 6x186x
why do you think that we have 2 town PR?samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
It wasn't my intent to divide people by throwing suspicion on ShinRun. I was just pointing out that I didn't understand Shinrun's reasoning for role claiming (especially with such a valuable role) and that this is what I came up with tryibng to make sense of their action. I also wanted to warn the two town with role to not roleclaim in case ShinRun really is a scum.abraker wrote: 6cx2d
If mafia are veterans in this game they know how to play this out: Divide and conquer.
vote: SamX500
samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
The setup is NewD3, so there are 2 town PRigorsprite wrote: 6x186x
why do you think that we have 2 town PR?samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
It wasn't my intent to divide people by throwing suspicion on ShinRun. I was just pointing out that I didn't understand Shinrun's reasoning for role claiming (especially with such a valuable role) and that this is what I came up with tryibng to make sense of their action. I also wanted to warn the two town with role to not roleclaim in case ShinRun really is a scum.abraker wrote: 6cx2d
If mafia are veterans in this game they know how to play this out: Divide and conquer.
vote: SamX500
Already prodded once, and put his slot up for replacement after confirming that a moderation error happened.Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q
He hasn't made a single post, why isn't he prodded?
(Repeat) Replacing manishmathur. Sorry for g you up by mistake.manishmathur wrote: 49y5n
bro when the fuck did I participated and i dont even know wtf is newd3
Understandable. I hope this game doesn't die out.DCT wrote: 4w3f2c
Already prodded once, and put his slot up for replacement after confirming that a moderation error happened.Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q
He hasn't made a single post, why isn't he prodded?
I was referring to NotRaffi
[quote="NotRaffi"]sorry for not being active my dudes, was out for a while and need to preserve data, I'm just gonna read things
Should no one replace manishmathur in the next 36 hours, he get to keep his slot.DCT wrote: 4w3f2c
Already prodded once, and put his slot up for replacement after confirming that a moderation error happened.Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q
He hasn't made a single post, why isn't he prodded?
(Repeat) Replacing manishmathur. Sorry for g you up by mistake.manishmathur wrote: 49y5n
bro when the fuck did I participated and i dont even know wtf is newd3
What are trying to say with this? This game literally cannot be C1 or C2. I am going under the assumption you circled options that we can rule out.igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
The setup is NewD3, so there are 2 town PRigorsprite wrote: 6x186x
why do you think that we have 2 town PR?samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
It wasn't my intent to divide people by throwing suspicion on ShinRun. I was just pointing out that I didn't understand Shinrun's reasoning for role claiming (especially with such a valuable role) and that this is what I came up with tryibng to make sense of their action. I also wanted to warn the two town with role to not roleclaim in case ShinRun really is a scum.abraker wrote: 6cx2d
If mafia are veterans in this game they know how to play this out: Divide and conquer.
vote: SamX500![]()
It contains 2 PRs.ClevelandsMyBro wrote: 58np
yea if shin is telling the truth and the game does contain 1 PR then i would legit think this game is dunzos.
scum suggestion, try againShinRun wrote: 4p6j2
So what are our plan
I suggest not voting anyone off
Not voting now is gonna suck later cause you have more chance voting out a PR if mafia has not done so by then.ghoulybits wrote: v2x52
I think for now that no votes is probably a solid option. At the very least, even if he's suspicious, I don't think ShinRun should be voted. If he is telling the truth, that would be a major loss for town. If he's lying, then we'll probably figure that out by the next day.
It doesn't make sense for shin to role claim because he did not use any braincells when doing so. If I learned anything about how entirety of town thinks in the past whatever games it is that it always seems to have an ass for brain. The fact that there are people here hoping that there this game is not 1 PR proves this fact. It's already confirmed there are 2 PRs wtf guys.samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
It wasn't my intent to divide people by throwing suspicion on ShinRun. I was just pointing out that I didn't understand Shinrun's reasoning for role claiming (especially with such a valuable role) and that this is what I came up with tryibng to make sense of their action. I also wanted to warn the two town with role to not roleclaim in case ShinRun really is a scum.abraker wrote: 6cx2d
If mafia are veterans in this game they know how to play this out: Divide and conquer.
vote: SamX500
because not voting anyone off helps scum in the long runNotRaffi wrote: 171b11
Why is "not voting anyone off" always a "scum suggestion" ?
Then vote me off before I get a stroke. Scum cant risk with role claim like this becauseNotRaffi wrote: 171b11
What if shin is actually not capping
So in mean time can you tell me how this game workDCT wrote: 4w3f2c
Should no one replace manishmathur in the next 36 hours, he get to keep his slot.DCT wrote: 4w3f2c
Already prodded once, and put his slot up for replacement after confirming that a moderation error happened.Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q
He hasn't made a single post, why isn't he prodded?
(Repeat) Replacing manishmathur. Sorry for g you up by mistake.manishmathur wrote: 49y5n
bro when the fuck did I participated and i dont even know wtf is newd3
community/forums/posts/1062604manishmathur wrote: 49y5n
So in mean time can you tell me how this game workDCT wrote: 4w3f2c
Should no one replace manishmathur in the next 36 hours, he get to keep his slot.DCT wrote: 4w3f2c
Already prodded once, and put his slot up for replacement after confirming that a moderation error happened.Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q
He hasn't made a single post, why isn't he prodded?
(Repeat) Replacing manishmathur. Sorry for g you up by mistake.manishmathur wrote: 49y5n
bro when the fuck did I participated and i dont even know wtf is newd3
I understand fully nopeabraker wrote: 6cx2d
community/forums/posts/1062604manishmathur wrote: 49y5n
So in mean time can you tell me how this game workDCT wrote: 4w3f2c
Should no one replace manishmathur in the next 36 hours, he get to keep his slot.DCT wrote: 4w3f2c
Already prodded once, and put his slot up for replacement after confirming that a moderation error happened.Julian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q
He hasn't made a single post, why isn't he prodded?
(Repeat) Replacing manishmathur. Sorry for g you up by mistake.manishmathur wrote: 49y5n
bro when the fuck did I participated and i dont even know wtf is newd3
sounds like youre begging for the other PR at night to prove your innocence.ShinRun wrote: 4p6j2
The other PR should be a cop or tracker, the person with the ability could literally use the ability on me to see if I’m lying or not. A cop should be able to see my alignment and tracker can see if I protected someone with my ability. Worst case scenario, mafia kill me.
bad idea, you are basically saying to other PR to roleclaim day 2ShinRun wrote: 4p6j2
The other PR should be a cop or tracker, the person with the ability could literally use the ability on me to see if I’m lying or not. A cop should be able to see my alignment and tracker can see if I protected someone with my ability. Worst case scenario, mafia kill me.
If we vote out a town today and mafia kill tonight, it would be 5-2igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
bad idea, you are basically saying to other PR to roleclaim day 2ShinRun wrote: 4p6j2
The other PR should be a cop or tracker, the person with the ability could literally use the ability on me to see if I’m lying or not. A cop should be able to see my alignment and tracker can see if I protected someone with my ability. Worst case scenario, mafia kill me.
I think my main reasoning is that a lot of people in this game have either been extremely inactive or have otherwise given very little input other than posting. Those people are more likely to go under the radar when it comes time to choose someone to vote out (and choosing someone to vote out d1 is often just a random selection). If one or both scum are inactive during this period, they likely won't be considered as someone "worthy" of voting out. For example (and this is not a serious accusation, so please do not take it as one), what if Manish or whoever ends up in Manish's slot is scum? We would have literally no way of telling at this point, considering he knows absolutely zilch about how to play mafia and would likely show no suspicious activity. When it comes time for people to make a random vote or a vote solely based off of suspicion, they would likely leave him out of their considerations, considering he has said almost nothing besides that he doesn't know the game at all. Because of that, I think it's risky to vote anyone before we get everyone actively participating and showing their logic.samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
@ghoulybits
You say "I feel like voting someone off carries a lot more risk than it does reward right now". Is that just a guts feeling or is there any actual reasoning behind it?
so we should vote for who is less activeghoulybits wrote: v2x52
I think my main reasoning is that a lot of people in this game have either been extremely inactive or have otherwise given very little input other than posting. Those people are more likely to go under the radar when it comes time to choose someone to vote out (and choosing someone to vote out d1 is often just a random selection). If one or both scum are inactive during this period, they likely won't be considered as someone "worthy" of voting out. For example (and this is not a serious accusation, so please do not take it as one), what if Manish or whoever ends up in Manish's slot is scum? We would have literally no way of telling at this point, considering he knows absolutely zilch about how to play mafia and would likely show no suspicious activity. When it comes time for people to make a random vote or a vote solely based off of suspicion, they would likely leave him out of their considerations, considering he has said almost nothing besides that he doesn't know the game at all. Because of that, I think it's risky to vote anyone before we get everyone actively participating and showing their logic.samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
@ghoulybits
You say "I feel like voting someone off carries a lot more risk than it does reward right now". Is that just a guts feeling or is there any actual reasoning behind it?
In addition, when it comes to voting out someone who's been more active in this game, I specifically have qualms with attempting to vote ShinRun, as I think that he's 1. an idiot who would actually roleclaim d1 and 2. most likely the town doctor. Therefore, that combined with the lack of any evidence to draw upon means that I would rather not vote someone out without an extremely compelling reason.
This is probably just word soup, so let me know if I need to clarify anything.
The thought of you dropping roleclaim idea sounds pretty scum.abraker wrote: 6cx2d
I can't believe we are arguing over when to roleclaim
How about we do scum hunting?
Because it's too early to even consider that. It takes away focus from what we should be doing: SCUM HUNTINGJulian_Kaiser wrote: c5t1q
The thought of you dropping roleclaim idea sounds pretty scum.abraker wrote: 6cx2d
I can't believe we are arguing over when to roleclaim
How about we do scum hunting?
Vote: abraker
Then please explain why you are voting ShinRun so early. If they are truly town doctor, then us eliminating them means scum won't have to kill them and will be able to try and kill the second PR.igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
hey, i'm reformed nowsamX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
I am most suspicious of igorsprite right now because they are acting very cooperative, which from previous game I have learned that they are mostly cooperative when being scum.![]()
oke, i will wait and see what happens.samX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
Then please explain why you are voting ShinRun so early. If they are truly town doctor, then us eliminating them means scum won't have to kill them and will be able to try and kill the second PR.igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
hey, i'm reformed nowsamX500 wrote: 4e1z5d
I am most suspicious of igorsprite right now because they are acting very cooperative, which from previous game I have learned that they are mostly cooperative when being scum.![]()
And if they are scum, they will be mostly revealed tommorow by them being still alive. With the off-chance that scum plays with fire and leaves them alive.
To me it seems like you are trying to get a free kill on a town PR.
Please refer to the latest vote count post for deadline.igorsprite wrote: 6x186x
i didn't even notice that we only have 1 day left
i agree with clevelands, shin's roleclaim doesn't mean that he is town and him suggesting nolim contributes to my suspicions. idk why abraker insists that shin is town.
Vote: Shinrun