Problem details: I noticed that the rank of the play on a beatmap with the higher PP is used rather than the play with the higher score.

E.g. I initially get an A-rank 200PP play with HDDT. Later, I FC the same map with HDHR but with lower PP and higher score. However on my profile, the A-rank counter (see SS below) does NOT go down.

How can I find the beatmaps that I have S-rank on (higher score) even though it's reflecting an A-rank on my profile?


Video or screenshot showing the problem:



osu! version: Stable 20250401.2 (latest)

i slider broke wrote: 303o24

E.g. I initially get an A-rank 200PP play with HDDT. Later, I FC the same map with HDHR but with lower PP and higher score. However on my profile, the A-rank counter (see SS below) does NOT go down.

Please link actual examples of scores you're suspecting of behaving like that because that sounds wrong.

spaceman_atlas wrote: 454748

i slider broke wrote: 303o24

E.g. I initially get an A-rank 200PP play with HDDT. Later, I FC the same map with HDHR but with lower PP and higher score. However on my profile, the A-rank counter (see SS below) does NOT go down.

Please link actual examples of scores you're suspecting of behaving like that because that sounds wrong.

Here, I tried simulating it. First I set an A-rank worth 51PP. A-rank counter on profile is 2715. Then I set S-rank with higher score worth 18PP. In the client it says I have S-rank on map but A-rank counter on profile still shows 2715 instead of 2714.
Beatmap: scores/4852917866 (Normal difficulty)

Edit: Did this have to do with an update around December 2024? Because I noticed that I got around 300 A-ranks added to the counter even though I don't recall setting that many in December (I track my monthly progress)

i slider broke wrote: 303o24

Here, I tried simulating it. First I set an A-rank worth 51PP. A-rank counter on profile is 2715. Then I set S-rank with higher score worth 18PP. In the client it says I have S-rank on map but A-rank counter on profile still shows 2715 instead of 2714.
Beatmap: scores/4852917866 (Normal difficulty)

A while back rank counts were changed to use lazer rank rules. That is the probable point of confusion here. Using stable rules, that score is an S because it has less than 10% 100s, but with lazer rules the main requirement for S changed to >=95% accuracy (and no misses) which this score fails to clear.

As to how to find the beatmaps where this happened - your best bet is probably the “rank achieved” filter on the beatmap listing.

spaceman_atlas wrote: 454748

i slider broke wrote: 303o24

Here, I tried simulating it. First I set an A-rank worth 51PP. A-rank counter on profile is 2715. Then I set S-rank with higher score worth 18PP. In the client it says I have S-rank on map but A-rank counter on profile still shows 2715 instead of 2714.
Beatmap: scores/4852917866 (Normal difficulty)

As to how to find the beatmaps where this happened - your best bet is probably the “rank achieved” filter on the beatmap listing.

Ah ok that makes more sense. It's gonna be tedious finding such scores TT
Thanks for the explanation

Edit: I think you guys should implement a filter for accuracy achieved in stable