Sign In To Proceed 435v5c

Don't have an ? 473g1v

osu! to create your own !
forum

Greatest Idea Mafia 3 - Game Over 6c2i1m

posted
Total Posts
621
show more
I thought I'm already done with frosting's banter but oh well

I wouldn't really recommend a nolynch D1.

Birdy wrote: 3z4n6h

Sorry, been away, first we got shitfaced and last night we were working on cosplays slightly hungover. Doesn't get more finnweebish than that.

Vote: AutoMedic

Zaph seems a bit agitated. I kinda want to believe Aomi is just new to this, but slight FoS in that direction nevertheless. Zexion and Frostings are still coo'.
Wait what I thought this wasn't the case

Frostings was trying to push the Navziel - AutoMedic alignment so hard that he forgot that he's doing some stupid shit again. I wouldn't really call stupid but it's as effective as talking to a rock.

Birdy wrote: 3z4n6h

Zaph, what could possibly be better than Mafia Supersaint?

Birdy wrote: 3z4n6h

Don't FOS me Frostings you're always doing stupid shit as town :?
I'm not cherrypicking, but you're a really good contrarian aren't you. However, this is not enough to warrant a vote.

Wouldn't it be funny if we had a SNB - Frosting scum. FoS: Frostings
also it's already less than 24hrs before deadline we should be able to come up with a decision at that time

Zaphkael wrote: 70351m

Hey guys dont read as null im town tnx

also wtf is this shitposting here (this is why i love mafia here kek)

automedic: why does frostings seem scum to you?
oh yeah i forgot to answer this question i think

The reason why I think Frosting is scum because of two reasons

1. Agenda pushing at D1 (this is really stupid, considering that if you push some agenda that doesn't make any sense whatsoever, you'll look like a scum.)
2. Being stubborn. Again, this might be another Setsuen styled approach so I think Frostings is either mafia or third party.

SNB on the other hand, what he/she clearly lacks is trying to look for scumslip opportunities instead of personally tripping my ass in this gane. Believe me when I make a roleclaim at D2 and I can prove it tonight.
oh yeah i forgot the rule of thumb

newbies are always mafia

AutoMedic wrote: 4y1

oh yeah i forgot the rule of thumb

newbies are always mafia
wouldn't it be safer to choose town because (I think) it's generally harder to play as mafia because there's a minority of you?
idk im always one for safer routes lol
yeah new players are always mafia :oops:

also what do you mean agenda pushing? We just need to Lynch AutoMedic Day1, then Navi Day2. No agenda here :)
literally a free game ;)

Frostings wrote: l110

yeah new players are always mafia :oops:

also what do you mean agenda pushing? We just need to Lynch AutoMedic Day1, then Navi Day2. No agenda here :)
literally a free game ;)
but that's wrong

Frostings wrote: l110

yeah new players are always mafia :oops:

also what do you mean agenda pushing? We just need to Lynch AutoMedic Day1, then Navi Day2. No agenda here :)
literally a free game ;)
You're literally setsuen so I'm going to give up on your conversation
Its too dangerous to roleclaim yet but I'll prove tonight that I'm not scum

I really want to know why SNB voted me. I stopped shitposting a few pages ago and if he could just read my fucking iso's instead of being a judgmental twat it would be great.
so who do we lynch now? :v
there's not really much time left until the deadline i don't think ??
yeah we really need to make a solid choice

i:'ll go do what town wants to do I guess. I'll just turn into a scapegoat if I push through something unless of course it's really obvious to me and I can prove it

btw this is my last post of the day bc univ so yeah
i just realised the "elitist fuckers" thing was part of your signature and not just at the end of your posts

can good people vote zaphkael? thanks

that means u too, birdy

unless ur not
i want to believe zaph is innocent but on the other hand i really don't know who to vote and the amount of time left isn't helping one bit
roles aren't even alignment-indicative in this game
well, most of them anyways
MBomb
As I already said, a Zaph lynch feels a lot better to me than an AutoMedic lynch, I know this isn't exactly the best reasoning because AtE is generally scummy, but it generally seemed very genuine to me his annoyance in multiple of his posts, so...

Vote: Zaph
MBomb
Sorry Zaph, I'd just rather not have a no lynch.

Frostings wrote: l110

roles aren't even alignment-indicative in this game
well, most of them anyways
well, no shit genius because this is greatest idea

i wont even be surprised if we have a third party serial killer
also who the fuck is AtE

AutoMedic wrote: 4y1

also who the fuck is AtE
Appeal to Emotion
basically ''if you lynch me, you'll lose''
MBomb

Aomi wrote: 2q6w66

AutoMedic wrote: 4y1

also who the fuck is AtE
Appeal to Emotion
basically ''if you lynch me, you'll lose''
Well, that's not what I meant by AtE, I meant his aggression towards stuff in general seemed pretty genuine, whilst emotion isn't the best thing to trust, idk it's just giving me a town feel right now.
said the newbie
"newbie"
automedic if you are not voting zaph, we're voting you

then u have more time for univ

- Magic Bomb - wrote: 5w14d

Well, that's not what I meant by AtE, I meant his aggression towards stuff in general seemed pretty genuine, whilst emotion isn't the best thing to trust, idk it's just giving me a town feel right now.
oh ok, sorry )":

metal sonic1 wrote: 22506x

said the newbie

metal sonic1 wrote: 22506x

"newbie"
Topic Starter
Vote Count 1.10

AutoMedic (4) - Frostings, Zexion, Birdy, Zaphkael [L-1]
Zaphkael (3) - metal sonic1, Navizel, - Magic Bomb - [L-2]
Frostings (1) - AutoMedic

Not Voting (1) - Aomi

With 9 Alive it takes 5 to Lynch.
Please let me know if you see any mistakes
Deadline in 13 hours and a half!
Vote: Zaphkael

i'm not really feeling the AM lynch plus I feel like I can trust MB so I'll follow up
i am not liking the taste of this wagon but considering this game is multiball.... meh
What is going on.

Hold on let me read.
Okay so we suddenly got a Zaph wagon.

I don't really like it.

Zaph hasn't been particularlly helpful this game, but I don't really see strong reasons to lynch him other than his backpedaling on the MS1 1vs1.

AutoMedic wrote: 4y1

Zaphkael wrote: 70351m

Hey guys dont read as null im town tnx

also wtf is this shitposting here (this is why i love mafia here kek)

automedic: why does frostings seem scum to you?
oh yeah i forgot to answer this question i think

The reason why I think Frosting is scum because of two reasons

1. Agenda pushing at D1 (this is really stupid, considering that if you push some agenda that doesn't make any sense whatsoever, you'll look like a scum.)
2. Being stubborn. Again, this might be another Setsuen styled approach so I think Frostings is either mafia or third party.

SNB on the other hand, what he/she clearly lacks is trying to look for scumslip opportunities instead of personally tripping my ass in this gane. Believe me when I make a roleclaim at D2 and I can prove it tonight.
You can do both as town. I don't really see how it's so much aligment indicative, also the "you musn't push an agenda or else you're scum" seems like just a bunch of WIFOM... also I don't even understand what you said about SNB, but I have it on my scummlist as for now... I think that's what you meant...

I think I'll be able to be online before the deadline.

Aomi wrote: 2q6w66

so who do we lynch now? :v
there's not really much time left until the deadline i don't think ??
are you really just going to just jump on a wagon and call it a day

Zexion wrote: 11654m

Zaph hasn't been particularlly helpful this game, but I don't really see strong reasons to lynch him other than his backpedaling on the MS1 1vs1.
its the strongest we have for lynching anyone, imo, unless you have a better reason for lynching someone else?


the problem is zaph is trying to look "helpful" but in actuality, as you agreed, not particularly helpful. this is in contrast to myself, navizel, birdy, etc who make it transparently clear that we don't want to be "particularly helpful" (unless when we want to)

see that is why i think he is scum but i dont necessarily townread all the people voting him with me, but considering that in greater idea everyone will be in different factions anyway im not as concerned
Lyncher? lol
GODDAMMIT

okay ill claim

So basically i had the choice between lyncher, saulus and judas.
lycher; im shit at this game so no thanks, i can barely make a case on scummy people
judas: would have been cool but i had a better option; i thought
saulus: this seemed THE shit for me: i am bad at this game so i would have gotten lynched anyway. because saulus starts as maf, i hoped to get all names and stuff so i could get lynched and give an ez town win...I NEVER GOT ANY NAMES I JUST PLAY AS A GODDAMN TRAITOR

so yeah i can prove that if you lynch me, but i can only prove im unlynchable once, for the other one you have to believe me on my word i guess
Ha I was right he was not town now get rekt

Also, wtf is a judas and Saulus sounds like bible names
Basically from what I read^

You start as >>>maf<<< and get the names of your teammate's, which are, incidentally, nobody.

RIP

Frostings wrote: l110

Lyncher? lol

You will be penalized for this comment.

Go eat 5 cupcakes :x
Someone Google Saulus for me before hammering thanks
huh what names
no sonic

as judas you start as town --> you become maf when lynched
as saulus you start as scum --> you become town when lynched

I thought i would get the names of my scumbuddies but essentially im a maf traitor i think...unless there really isnt any maf lol
also don't hammer zaph yet until we get everything we need
or dont hammer me and make me town when town is winning? :D :D :D
Topic Starter
Vote Count 1.11

AutoMedic (4) - Frostings, Zexion, Birdy, Zaphkael [L-1]
Zaphkael (4) - metal sonic1, Navizel, - Magic Bomb -, Aomi [L-1]
Frostings (1) - AutoMedic

With 9 Alive it takes 5 to Lynch.
Please let me know if you see any mistakes
10 hours and a half until deadline!

Friendly reminder that this game has the L-1 lynch rule, if deadline hits with 2 ppl at L-1 the person who reached L-1 first is lynched.

Zaphkael wrote: 70351m

no sonic

as judas you start as town --> you become maf when lynched
as saulus you start as scum --> you become town when lynched

I thought i would get the names of my scumbuddies but essentially im a maf traitor i think...unless there really isnt any maf lol
???? Not sure how it works in Greatest Idea or how Saulus works in general but the wiki says Saulus is an anti-town. Anti-town doesn't mean mafia. Anti-town in Greatest Idea can be Alien, Werewolf, Mafia, or Goo afaik.
What about his so-called lynch mechanics hack? Not to mention he could be lying about all this anyway but let's just have more info
@mod, is Saulus an anti-town or mafia?
Topic Starter

Navizel wrote: 1v6ad

@mod, is Saulus an anti-town or mafia?
http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?tit ... s_.2870.29

Saulus starts as mafia and has no knowledge of their partners, if their partners are all dead or inexistant Saulus is informed of this and gains the ability to night kill. If Saulus is lynched they dont flip and revive as a Vanilla Townie with a different win condition
THE TOWN SIDE :)
Best mod

Zaphkael wrote: 70351m

I thought i would get the names of my scumbuddies but essentially im a maf traitor i think...unless there really isnt any maf lol

Sakura wrote: 1q3420

Navizel wrote: 1v6ad

@mod, is Saulus an anti-town or mafia?
http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?tit ... s_.2870.29

Saulus starts as mafia and has no knowledge of their partners, if their partners are all dead or inexistant Saulus is informed of this and gains the ability to night kill. If Saulus is lynched they dont flip and revive as a Vanilla Townie with a different win condition
well there you go. besides, it would really be an easy win if you know your partners
Lynch him so that we get a confirmed town instantly.
is it actually worth wasting D1 lynch on Zaph? we know he's Saulus and I don't see any reason to lie about it.
Yes. Because we have <12h, we know he becomes confirmed town, and automedic probably isn't scum
We can no lynch too that's super cool

Frostings wrote: l110

THE TOWN SIDE :)
well I'm going to sleep and I probably won't be up before deadline so w/e
no
if he survives a lynch, we won't know whether he converted to town, or to scum
and I don't wanna waste a lynch just to he's one or the other
vig or investigator should go on him
Oh the reveal is not public?
Well pretty sure he's scum _now_ so stop being a boring ass wank and put your vote on

Or the vig/investigator is going to be on YOU 0:)
Well as much as I hate saying this sonic, I won't be conf town for the reason frostings said. I won't flip if you lynch me so i could be 1-shot unlynchable, judas or saulus. I dont see a reason to lie about this - my awesome plan didnt work for shit - but still, I could lie. Saying that im conf townie when lynched is just bad strategy lol.
btw automedic reached L-1 first so he will get lynched in 4 hours

i dont mind having him die lol
ill stay on the maf side for a while, prevents me to eat some nightkills
ok folks just hammer zaphkael thats my final decision

metal sonic1 wrote: 22506x

ok folks just hammer zaphkael thats my final decision
Totally not pushing an agenda.

This is hard btw.

Frostings wrote: l110

and I don't wanna waste a lynch just to he's one or the other
Same here. I believe Zaph's claim will be cleared in due time.
alright enough being afraid to claim

I am a supersaint and I can prove it. If birdy dies then either she got blocked or my claim is false

I drew town hirsute, town supersaint and one mafia blocker. I discarded mafia cards because I really want to go full town doctor right now
If i get lynched tommorow then it's frostings fault. If I get roleblocked tommorow then it's frosting's fault. I'm not really concerned or anything because supersaint is just good and I can backfire unless blocked

Sakura wrote: 1q3420

EXCEPTION: If there's a player at L-1 that player will be lynched at deadline.
I suppose this means AutoMedic gets lynched since he reached L-1 first.

Navizel wrote: 1v6ad

Aomi wrote: 2q6w66

so who do we lynch now? :v
there's not really much time left until the deadline i don't think ??
are you really just going to just jump on a wagon and call it a day
This is extremly newbie, not aligment indicative btw. I doing the exact same in one of my first games, not even intentionally.

AutoMedic wrote: 4y1

alright enough being afraid to claim

I am a supersaint and I can prove it. If birdy dies then either she got blocked or my claim is false

I drew town hirsute, town supersaint and one mafia blocker. I discarded mafia cards because I really want to go full town doctor right now
If i get lynched tommorow then it's frostings fault. If I get roleblocked tommorow then it's frosting's fault. I'm not really concerned or anything because supersaint is just good and I can backfire unless blocked
Wait what? How can you be blocked as supersaint? That activates inmediately!
oh

then good luck I guess. You guys can put out guesses in tommorow.

Zexion wrote: 11654m

metal sonic1 wrote: 22506x

ok folks just hammer zaphkael thats my final decision
Totally not pushing an agenda.

This is hard btw.
are you fucking stupid or fucking stupid? i just caught scum, he just claimed scum, fuck you and your agenda bullshit

if you dont want to play to win then dont fucking play the game
sorry for the outburst but did you miss the part where he claimed scum and i was totally absolutely 100% right and people are still being coo-coo about it

that includes you

by not hammering zaphkael it is equivalent to automedic being lynched. now, if you're right about automedic being scum, then i hold my peace, but if he does flip town i am going to flip the table
and then continue shitposting

or replace out
by the way, if automedic flip scum, that doesn't mean im wrong, zaphkael is still scum, but then i concede your point of view here for lynching automedic
i can also hammer automedic now so that it lets me autoquit if he is indeed town supersaint :)
i take ALL OF THAT back


if sakura does what i am thinking, this is the best case scenario

Zexion wrote: 11654m

This is extremly newbie, not aligment indicative btw. I doing the exact same in one of my first games, not even intentionally.
And I thought you don't want "newbie" as a reason. What changed?
it could be zexion's alignment
Well...if medic flips scum i want to be next
If he flips town pls let me stay maf xd

Im opportunistic af, why else did you think my setup C role was surv tracker and this one saulus lol
xDDDDDDDDDDddddd

Zaphkael wrote: 70351m

If he flips town pls let me stay maf xd
if we have a vig that can shoot you then that's already good

the only thing im worried about is the roleblocker. you guys need to lynch that person as fast as possible. im guessing most of you guys got the blocker card role
also you can make me flip now but dont let zaph hammer me because you guys are gonna get fucked

if i die in this game, please find that roleblocker. that is really essential. if the roleblock is town, then protect it at all costs. i guarantee we have a third party
1. I won't hammer, don't worry.
2. Vigging me is by far not your best option. You are making a vig lose its shot because you don't believe me, and therefore throw away some important shot and a possible townie?

I'm saulus and, as convenient as the mod said, I will be informed when the last real maf died. What would make me abstain from telling you so and get myself lynched to the winning side? Your logic makes no sense.

And don't say 'you could be judas' because that would mean that I would be town right now, and you would order a vig to shoot town.

Whats all the RB'er fuzz?

AutoMedic wrote: 4y1

also you can make me flip now but dont let zaph hammer me because you guys are gonna get fucked
umm why? i would love that
this is all upto chance I guess

anyone who hates taking risks is mafia.
And what is your point? This is the first time i can actually claim mafia without negative consequences.
Town can keep me around and make me town when scum died, until then im most likely bulletproof against maf kills (why would they shoot me lmao)
Scum can try to keep me from being lynched so they have an extra ''member'' that works as last resort goon
Im ' useful' for both alignments, in short. Isnt that the best opportunistic role ever?

Lmao do i even have to scumhunt? Well, i dunno who maf is (i have a feeling about players tho, check the reads i gave that u ignored) so i can just hunt the scummiest and its not my prob if town or not

Only downside is that im basically clickbait for 3rd party, if there is any.
Topic Starter
10 Minutes until deadline!
The newbie thing was just an attitude I ed in my first games. It hasn't changed what I think of Aomi (nullscum).

Also I think I missed the Sauulus claim.

But if MS1 said so and this is the best case scenario, I'll keep my vote where it is. We can 'convert' Zaph later.

metal sonic1 wrote: 22506x

i take ALL OF THAT back


if sakura does what i am thinking, this is the best case scenario
I get it now.

And I agree.
memes
Topic Starter
Deadline's over, game's paused, lynch scene coming
Topic Starter
After multiple arguments and trolling the town has decided to put AutoMedic on the chopping block. "lel you will die too" said Automedic

Final Vote Count Day 1

AutoMedic (4) - Frostings, Zexion, Birdy, Zaphkael [Lynch by default]
Zaphkael (4) - metal sonic1, Navizel, - Magic Bomb -, Aomi [L-1]
Frostings (1) - AutoMedic

AutoMedic Town Supersaint has been lynched
The town decides to gang up on Zaphkael for this crime!
Zaphkael has been lynched
Zaphkael has revived!

It is now Night 1, send all night actions to my inbox within 24 hours, you may change your actions as many time as you want before deadline, if no action is sent by deadline it'll count as No Action.
oh, supersaint triggers a "lynch reaction" rather than a "kill reaction"?
Topic Starter
Sorry i overslept, resolving night actions now
Topic Starter
After waking up, not 1, but 2 bodies lay out in the middle of the town center

- Magic Bomb - Hirsute Serial Killer has died Night 1
Frostings Alien Mason has died Night 1

It is now Day 2 and it lasts until 7/01 11:02 GMT-5

Vote Count 2.0

Not Voting (6) - Zaphkael, Zexion, Aomi, Navizel, metal sonic1, Birdy

With 6 Alive it takes 4 to Lynch.
I HATE YOU GUYS

I could've helped you out with saying when all maf was dead but no, you really wanted me dead and made me a vanilla fucking townie
Now i actually have to work T_T

I have to say tho
Hirsute sk wouldve been op
And lmao who chooses alien mason, i thought it was only ww/town who could be mason?
What In the fucking name of holy fucking shit.

This is just awesome.

Also I really don't buy the Saluus claim now.

Will post later.

Zaphkael wrote: 70351m

I HATE YOU GUYS

I could've helped you out with saying when all maf was dead but no, you really wanted me dead and made me a vanilla fucking townie
Now i actually have to work T_T

I have to say tho
Hirsute sk wouldve been op
And lmao who chooses alien mason, i thought it was only ww/town who could be mason?
didn't you kill yourself by voting AutoMedic or am I missing something
also memes
MBomb
fucking end me

gl whoever, i've already lost so xdddd
Basically im playing 4 games simultaneously and i forgot that i was the last to vote. Add to that that automedic said 'dont let him hammer me' and you guys didnt say that i actually was the last instead of snb...
Hell,now that i think of it, if i unvoted i was the only L-1 wagon and i would have been lynched anyway.

Im just angry because i couldve helped town more back when i was still a saulus (i dont even consider that as maf because its basically a maf traitor that sides with town when lynched) + i think im the only non PR right now + i hate being unable to choose

What i can contribute as townie (urgh) today: yesterday, i wasnt notified that i got NK powers and that there was no maf left, so there is still maf
I dont know if the nightkill was maf but i assume it was for the sake of not destroying my brains. It should be that the alien was killed by the sk.
This means: there could be more aliens but i dont think so (lmao who even chooses alien)
Other parties could be hiding but that would be stupid

Sorry for setup spec but this game would have been way easier for both me and you if you prevented my lynch. Period.

@zexion: sure, you can share us why you think i wasnt saulus, cuz i really want to know lol. Why the hell would i lie about that? If i was a non town1shot unlynchable i wouldve claimed town unlynchable for the sake of safety
If i was town unlyncha whyfakeclaim lmao
If i was that judas role i wouldve claimed judas because it starts as a townie. The people then pushing my lynch would be most likely scum wanting another member.
wtf is hirsute
ok so town must make up at least 50% of the starting population.

9 players

means at least 5 start as town

zaph mb frostings down

ok andd 1 town is down so basically we hunt for 1 remaining scum in 5 and zaphkael we lynch if that scum is found and we havent won
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply 1b384i